Monday, November 28, 2016

Truth sprouts from the earth (i)

TRUTH SPROUTS FROM THE EARTH


“Truth shall sprout from the earth”
Psalms 85:12



The mysterious verse, “Truth shall sprout from the earth” has been interpreted in various ways. For some, the verse implies that textual knowledge cannot substitute real life experience. Only experience can reveal a concept’s limitations, context, and potency. In this vein, the chassidic master, Reb Simcha Bunim of Pshischa, once quipped about the knowledge of a certain mystic, “He has studied the map of Paris but never walked its streets!” Having studied a map, one may know the location of every street by heart. Still, it would not be wise to ask him for directions since he can’t tell how beautiful, safe or congested any given route is. Only one who has walked the streets can offer sound directions. Along tese lines our sages teach, “There is none wiser than he who learns from experience.”[1] In essence, Reb Simcha Bunim was unimpressed with the knowledge of this particular mystic because it did not ‘sprout from the earth’. Unaccompanied by real life application, it lacked the element of truth.   

The Kotzker Rebbe had a different interpretation. According to him, just as the potential of a seed to become a plant is actualised when the seed is sown in the earth, one’s potential to be truthful and objective is only realized after one figuratively lowers the self to the earth in humility. This theme is echoed in the prayer, ‘Let my soul be as dust before all; open my heart to Your Torah’. Only after egoism is reduced can one study Torah with truth, that is, unclouded by the bias of self-interest.[2] 

            Mumbaz, an aristocratic convert to Judaism during the Talmudic period, used this verse in another way.[3]  During prolonged famine, Mumbaz, out of exceptional generosity, exhausted his personal treasury to provide the community with relief. His family complained, “Your father gathered treasure and built upon his father’s treasure, but you are squandering it all!” He retorted, “My father hid the treasures below [in this world]; I am hiding them above [in Heaven]…He hid them where they can yet be stolen, while I am hiding them where they cannot be stolen…for ‘Truth shall sprout from the earth.’  Mumbaz meant that the way to merit true – eternal/Divine - goodness in the spiritual realm is by performing altruistic acts on earth - for “truth shall sprout from the earth.”          


Perhaps the most intriguing use of the verse is found in a Midrash describing the process that preceded the creation of Adam, the progenitor of humanity: 


‘As G-d was about to create Adam, four spiritual qualities disputed as to whether he should be created:
Kindness said, ‘Let him be created for he will perform acts of kindnesses.’
Truth countered, ‘Do not create him for he will be filled with falsehood’.
Righteousness asserted, ‘Create him, for he will perform acts of righteousness’.
Peace responded, ‘Do not create him for he will be filled with strife.”...
G-d cast Truth to the earth and said, “Truth shall sprout from the earth.”[4]

In the next few blog posts we will look at some of the mystical commentaries on this enigmatic Midrash.




[1] Akeidat Yitzchak, Parshiat Noach
[2] Likuttei Sichot, Vol. 30, p. 106 
[3] Babylonian Talmud Baba Batra 11a
[4] Midrash Genesis Rabbah 8:5

Thursday, November 24, 2016

On 'The pursuit of Truth'

ON THE ‘PURSUIT OF TRUTH’


‘Truth, Truth shall you pursue’
Targum Onkeles on Deuteronomy 18:20 


People commonly speak about the ‘pursuit of Truth’, a phrase that, to many, suggests that Truth is a limited quality or amount of information somewhere out there, waiting to be discoved through a combination of time and effort. Although this may be the case with ‘minor truths’ such as finding out who spilled juice on the kitchen floor, what 6x6 equals, or what causes the heart to beat, here I’m talking about Truth with a capital ‘T’ – the Holy Grail.    Indeed, many philosophers have naively ventured to discover the Truth: the hidden universalities that make life intelligible and clear, reconciling all contradictions and solving all mysteries. And, though some misguided scholars have professed to have found it, the vast majority find that the further they pursue it, the more it eludes them. Like chasing one’s shadow, the faster one runs after it, the faster it runs away.            

On the verse, “If you will listen, listen to the voice of the L-rd your G-d,”[1] the Midrash comments, “Happy is the one whose ‘listenings’ are to Me, hovering always at My doorways; door within door...”[2] Rabbi Yehuda Leib Alter of Ger, the author of ‘Sefat Emet’, in commenting on this Midrash explains how one must never feel he has conclusively grasped a Torah teaching, for its depth is limitless. This, he adds, is implied by the repetition of the word listen in the original verse cited above. That is, even if you have already listened and understood, listen again... and again - for a higher grasp forever awaits you.[3] The Midrash’s metaphor of a door within a door is apt. The Hebrew word for doorway is delet, denoting emptiness, for a doorway is merely an empty space.[4] Yet, it is precisely this emptiness that allows movement from one room to the next. In respect to Torah study, this implies that one who feels ignorant and empty of a teaching’s true meaning is open to advance to a new level of understanding, but one who feels he has already grasped the truth, closes the passage before him.[5] Herein lays one explanation for the mitzvah (commandment) of fixing Mezuzot on our doorposts. The Mezuzah, a piece of parchment with Torah written on it, represents Torah study in general, while the doorpost on which it is affixed signifies the openess prerequisite for proper and penetrating Torah study.[6]  
        
Rabbi Yehuda Leib’s commentary on the Midrash above suggests that even when one has grasped truth, one must forever remain open to further or deeper truth. In contrast, the Ben Ish Chai, a 19th Century Sephardic mystic from Bagdad, takes the elusive nature of truth a step further, defining it as G-d’s perspective of reality which categorically transcends human grasp. Here the Ben Ish Chai draws our attention to the blessing recited after the Haftarah reading, which concludes, “And all His words are true and righteous”. He points out that the first and last letters of the Hebrew word for righteous, צדק, are neighbours in the Hebrew alphabet, the Aleph-bet, while the first and last letters of truth, אמת, are at the Aleph-Bet’s opposite ends.[7] This, he explains, signifies two different ways that G-d governs our lives. Sometimes G-d reveals to us how the puzzle pieces of our lives fit neatly together, when things make sense to us and Divine providence is evident. At these times we refer to G-d’s as ‘righteous’. At other times, however, G-d distances the puzzle pieces from each other, rendering us incapable of connecting them together. Events then appear to make little sense and leave us asking ‘Why, G-d, is this happening?’ In such instances we refer to G-d’s conduct as ‘true. Meaning that even though we cannot connect the puzzle pieces of reality together as they are spaced too far apart, we still affirm that from G-d’s perspective everything is cohesive, precise, and orderly. G-d can connect the furthest pieces of life together - the Aleph, א, with the Tav, ת. Truth, אמת, rests with G-d alone.[8]

The above two images of Truth (that there are eternally higher levels of Truth to strive towards and that Truth is, by definition, reality beyond human grasp) may dampen our enthusiasm to purse Truth, as it appears to be a futile quest. In reality, the opposite is correct. The fact that Truth is forever beyond our grasp is highly motivational: Truth charms us into an endless adventure.[9]

The closest one comes to finding Truth is realizing its endlessness. Before Truth one stands empty and humble and from within these feelings a childlike curiosity springs forth to explore and discover reality.[10] And the stronger the curiosity, the more openly does Truth glow within. Put in other words, the extent to which one is drawn to pursue the infinite Truth, and the more deeply one feels the infinite journey of discovery that lies ahead, is the extent to which one has found Truth. Perhaps the Kotzker Rebbe put it most elegantly: “the pursuing is itself the finding!”[11]




[1] Devarim, 28:1
[2] Midrash Rabbah, Devarim 7:2
[3] Sefat Emet, Sefer Devarim, Parshat Tavo, 5632
[4] Wisdom of the Hebrew Alphabet, p.78, citing the Maharal
[5] For a similar concept see Rabbi Menachem Mendel Schneerson, Likutei Sichot, Vol.1, p.129 
[6] Sefat Emet, ibid
[7] Ben Ish chai, ‘Od Yoseph Chai’, Parshat Nosso
[8]Ibid 
[9] Rabbi Adin Steinsaltz, The Thirteen Petalled Rose, Basic Books, 1980, p.133  
[10]  Hence man’s Good Inclination is referred to as a child, Kohelet 4:13
[11] Rabbi Abraham J.Twerski, Rebbes and Chassidim, p.91

Monday, November 21, 2016

The ring of truth: cohesion, recollection, resonance

    THE ‘RING OF TRUTH’ 

“Words of truth are easily recognized”
                                       Babylonian Talmud Sotah 9b


When deciding whether to create Adam, G-d ‘sought counsel’ from the heavenly court. The court polarised: Kindness favoured Adam’s existence; Truth opposed; Righteousness asserted, ‘Create him’, while Peace objected. To form a majority in favour of Adam’s creation, G-d excluded Truth from the debate.[1] 

Why, asked the Kotzker Rebbe, did G-d not exclude Peace instead of Truth? He answered, since ‘words of Truth are easily recognized’, had Truth remained in the debate it would have outweighed the opposing majority!”[2]

Indeed, why are ‘words of truth easily recognized’? What gives truth the power to outweigh a majority?  

Cohesion: 


 “Truth is as light to the eyes”
    Tosefet Lamivchar 35 

“...when two Biblical passages contradict each other, the meaning is determined by a third verse which reconciles them”
Sifra, Introduction



 Truth causes disjointed or contradictory pieces of information to snap cohesively together.[3] The following analogy illustrates this idea most simply: 
Three people walking together in the dark bumped into an object and began arguing about its identity. One claimed it was a whip; another was certain it was a post, and the last was adamant it was a hose. Puzzled by their conflicting testimonies, they returned to the place of the mysterious object, torch in hand. They discovered the object was an elephant. Instantly, it became clear how all three varying opinions were formed: the first person bumped into the elephant’s tail, the second, into its legs, and the third, its trunk. With the complete truth, everything fitted neatly into place. 

 One notable example in the Torah of truth bringing cohesion is Joseph’s interpretation of his fellow prisoners’ dreams. Noticing that Pharaoh’s chief cupbearer and baker were distressed, Joseph asked what was troubling them. They replied that they were confused by the obscure and fragmented symbolism of their dreams the previous night. After Joseph interpreted the chief cupbearer’s dream, the chief baker, “saw how good he [Joseph] had interpreted.”[4] What does the word ‘good’ mean in this context? The first time ‘good’ is used in the Torah is in reference to the creation of light where, “...G-d saw that the light is good.”[5] What is the connection between light and good? The Maharal explains why the Hebrew word for evening is ‘erev’, and the Hebrew word for morning is ‘boker’. With sunset, the boundaries between objects become blurred, making it difficult to distinguish one object from another, or to perceive exact locations. Confusion and insecurity reign. The word erev, which connotes a mixing, reflects this confused state. With morning light, however, the ability to discern objects is restored. The Hebrew word boker aptly denotes discernment and clarity.[6] Light is therefore seen as ‘good’ because it engenders clarity and coherence. Accordingly, when the chief baker described Joseph’s interpretation as ‘good’, it was because he observed the interpretation as coalescing the chaotic dream images into a cohesive whole.[7]

Incidentally, the term ‘saw’ precedes the term ‘good’ in both the Pasuk  mentioned above regarding Hashem’s creation, and the chief baker’s comment on Yosef’s dream interpretation.[8] How is vision related to “good”? One of the differences between hearing and seeing is that one hears sounds in a temporal sequence, note after note or word after word, while sight allows one to perceive many details simultaneously. When observing a painting, one does not gaze at one brush stroke at a time and gradually build up an impression of the image. Rather, the instant one looks at the painting, it can be perceived in its entirety. Hence, sight provides a sense of wholeness, cohesion, and clarity; similar to our interpretation of the term ‘good’. 

The coherence produced by the revelation of truth is suggested in the word for truth, מתא, itself. The letters of the word are as distant from each other as possible in the Aleph-Bet; א and ת are at opposite ends, while מ, in the middle, is equidistant from them both. In the word מתא, however, all three letters combine, depicting the mental coherence experienced by the revelation of truth, where disjointed bits of information snap neatly into place.    




 Recollection:



“...lest you forget the things which your eyes have seen...the day you stood before the Lord your God at Chorev [Sinai]”
Deuteronomy 16:3

 The Talmud relates that, while in the womb, a foetus is taught the entire Torah. At birth, however, an angel slaps it above the upper lip,[9] causing it to forget the Torah it learnt.[10] Rabbi Tzvi Elimelech of Dinov points out the paradox: if G-d causes us to forget the Torah at birth, why does He teach it to us in the first place? And if G-d instructs us to learn Torah - evident in the mitzvah to learn Torah - why does He cause us to forget it?   Rabbi Elimelech explains that G-d has two related considerations. He desires that people exercise free choice in learning and practising Torah so He can reward them for their accomplishments. He thus makes people forget the Torah at birth - so they are required to seek it out themselves. However, G-d also knows that, [as fish cannot escape the water and fly], a coarse earthly human cannot properly grasp the heavenly wisdom of Torah without assistance. G-d thus imbues the foetus with Torah, making it a part of the person, which he can later relate to and access during his time on earth if he so chooses.[11]

In short: the Torah taught in the womb provides one with the ability to relate to Torah in this world. Yet, it is still up to each individual to recapture the Torah and learn it independently, bringing it out from the subconscious into everyday practice. This process implies that exposure to truth is not about discovery but recovery.  In learning a truth one merely remembers what he forgot at birth.[12] It is the sense of recollection that explains why truth tends to ‘ring true’. 



Resonance:

“Words that come from the heart enter the heart”
Moshe Ibn Ezra, Shirat Yisrael


“And they [Jacob’s sons] told him [Jacob], ‘Josef is still alive! He is the ruler of all Egypt.’ But his [Jacob’s] heart became numb, and he did not believe them.”[13] The Midrash comments, “Such is a liar’s fate: even when telling the truth, he is not believed.”[14] Jacob did not believe his sons because they had previously lied to him, stating that Joseph was dead, when in reality he was only sold into slavery.  In contrast, when Delilah asked Samson to disclose the secret of his superhuman strength, he lied to her a few times before stating the truth, yet Delilah still knew when his words were genuine.[15] Explaining how she knew, the Talmud comments, “Nikarim divrei emet – Words of truth are easily recognised.”[16]

Why was Jacob unable to discern the truth in his son’s words while Delilah recognised the truth in Samson’s? And how do we reconcile the axiom, “A liar, even when telling the truth is not believed” with, “Words of truth are easily recognised”?[17] There are two types of falsehood; Sheker and Badai.  Sheker refers to a situation where a person knows he is lying, whereas Badai refers to a person who mistakenly thinks he is correct. Jacob’s son’s engaged in Badai. They convened a court of law which found Josef guilty of treason and deserving of capital punishment.[18] To avoid killing him themselves they sold Joseph into slavery, assuming G-d would complete the sentence by ensuring his death. When they informed Jacob that Josef had been killed, they really believed it and - their words emanated from their hearts. Therefore, when they later told the truth about Josef, though they appeared sincere, Jacob did not believe them, for they had already shown a predisposition for false beliefs. Samson, however, spoke Sheker when attempting to mislead Delilah; he knew he was lying to her. Therefore, when he finally told the truth with transparency and sincerity she recognised it. 

Another incident in the Torah highlighting the resonance of truth involves Judah approaching his brother Joseph, (then the viceroy of Egypt), in an attempt to exonerate his family.[19] The usual protocol when addressing the viceroy was for a subject to speak to an interpreter, who then relayed the message to the viceroy. Judah, however, requested permission to speak to Joseph directly.[20] Why was this so important to him? Judah understood that words issued from the heart are recognised as genuine because they resonate with the listener. He therefore sought to address Joseph directly, to impress upon him the sincerity of his words. Had he communicated through an interpreter, this resonance of truth might have been lost.[21]

A more contemporary incident involving Rabbi Yisrael Meyer Kagan, the Chafetz Chaim, also demonstrates how sincerity ‘rings true’ and can influence authority. In the late 1800’s, the Polish government prohibited shechita, the ritual slaughter of animals. This rule made it almost impossible for Jews to eat meat without risking severe punishment. On behalf of Polish Jewry, the Chafetz Chaim met with a Polish official in an attempt to have the ban retracted. He pleaded passionately in Yiddish about the impact of the restriction on Poland’s Jews. When he finished speaking, the interpreter began to translate the Rabbi’s Yiddish into Polish. However, the official abruptly stopped him, saying, “I have heard enough; I need no translation!” The official was so moved by the sincerity of the Chafetz Chaim’s voice, he agreed to help lift the band, despite not understanding what had been said.




[1] Midrash Genesis Rabbah 8:5
[2] Oratz, Ephraim, ‘And Nothing But The Truth’ Judaica Press, New York, 1990, pp.131-132
[3]Rashi on Sotah 9b 
[4] Genesis 40:16
[5] Genesis 1:4
[6] Nachmonides on Genesis; Lowe, Rabbi Yehuda, Gevurot Hashem 
[7] Jacob refers to Joseph’s talent when he calls him ‘Ben Poret.’ The letters of ‘Poret’ can be rearranged to spell both ‘Tofer’, meaning to stitch together, and ‘Poter’, dream interpreter, for revealing dream content depends on the ability to stitch together fragmented dream images. Rabbi Schneur Zalman of Liadi, Maamarei Admur Hazaken 5565, p.196
[8] Similarly, when Moses is born the verse states, “They saw that he was good” (Exodus 2:2); again connecting vision with good. Rashi commenting on the word ‘good’ states that when Moses was born his home filled with light (Based on Babylonian Talmud Sotah 12a). 
[9]  I.e.The infants first nasal inhalation; Maharal, Gevurot Hashem, Sec.28
[10] Tanchuma, Pikudei, Sec.3; Babylonian Talmud Niddah 30b
[11] Rabbi Tzvi Elimelech of Divov, Bnei Yisaschar, Maamre Chodesh Sivan, Maamre 1 Sec. 7 
[12] Tikkunei Zohar, Tikun 70 
[13] Genesis 45:26
[14] Midrash Genesis Rabbah 94:3 
[15] Shoftim  16:18
[16] Babylonian Talmud Sotah 9b
[17] This question, and the following answer, are  adapted from an essay by rabbi Yochanan Zweig, ‘Liar, Liar’, posted on Torah.org  
[18] Seforno 37:25
[19] Genesis 44:18
[20] Ibid.
[21] Rabbi Levi Yitzchak of Berditchev, Kedushat Levi, Parshat VaYigash